Battle Over The Aurora Planned Parenthood: Is God Pro-Choice?
by Catherine Morgan

Yesterday I wrote a post on my personal blog titled "All Women's Rights Are Not Created Equal", in response to the controversy over the opening of a Planned Parenthood in Aurora.

With the "anti-choice" movement claiming to have God and the Bible on their side...What do you think? Why do "pro-lifers" believe that God wouldn't allow for "choice"? I'm a Christian and I believe in choice...does that mean I'm going to hell? I don't know what you think, but I'm pretty sure I'm not going to hell. Anyway, is hell even big enough for all the people that believe in choice?

Well, here is a sampling of what the blogosphere is saying.

From Planned Parenthood Aurora . . .

Unfortunately today’s ruling means that, yet again, we will have to reschedule appointments for our patients. Our main concern is that every day our health center is not open, more women go without pap tests, birth control supplies and breast exams. These are critical services that this community has been lacking and that we will provide.

The Chicago Tribune Web Edition reported . . .

The irony here is that Planned Parenthood, with its broad menu of low-cost services that also includes contraceptive counseling, pregnancy testing, adoption referrals and disease screening, almost certainly does more to lower the overall number of abortions (by providing the birth control that blocks unwanted pregnancies) and to save lives than all of the protests, prayer vigils and campaigns of harassment by its enemies put together.

From Real Women, Real Voices . . .

Apparently even when offering legal, constitutionally protected services, cities like Aurora will become gun-shy when anti-choice protesters become involved. Planned Parenthood of Chicago is going to federal court to try to force the city of Aurora to allow their new clinic to open as planned on September 18.

The Curvature - Aurora On My Mind . . .

Hey, generic men’s rights activist asshat, Planned Parenthood didn’t lie to anyone. They said that they were opening a medical center. They built a medical center. Just because you don’t like the kind of medical center it is doesn’t make it any less of a medical center. If the city doesn’t require their permit applicants to specify a particular practice (gynecology, podiatry, urology . . .), or if the city doesn’t properly examine permits before approving them, that’s the city of Aurora’s problem, not Planned Parenthood’s.

And secondly, are you serious? You’re honestly going to make an argument that Planned Parenthood shouldn’t be allowed because it “brings danger to the community,” when it’s assholes just like you who make working at Planned Parenthood such a dangerous experience. How exactly does Planned Parenthood cause danger on its own? Do you think that the nurses are going to go on a shooting spree in the neighborhood? Or that a zombie aborted embryo is going to come eat your brain? [Wait, don’t answer that.] No, actually, the problem would be one of your buddies shooting the place up. If you don’t want Planned Parenthood to be a dangerous place, stop making it so damn dangerous.

Gabriela Salvidea wrote a post titled "Planned Parenthood Seeks To Educate, and Train Community Members"

“A lot of people think of PP as a place you go to get a pregnancy test, or your birth control, and we do offer those services—you know, cancer screenings, all that good stuff,” said Cora Davidson, who coordinated the camp and is Field Organizer for the local Planned Parenthood. “But we also do things like advocacy, and going out and getting support for an issue. Teaching people about an issue and really trying to protect rights so we can provide our services.”

At Average Thoughts From Average Me, God Is Pro-Choice . . .

Planned Parenthood - the organization that strikes fear and anger in the hearts of Christians everywhere. Yet Planned Parenthood is not, and has never been, synonymous with abortion. The organization provides services including STD testing, sexual health resources and education, pregnancy testing, pap smears, birth control and yes, abortions.

I know the facts - I know that Planned Parenthood facilities perform approximately 17% of the total US abortions performed each year. And I also know there are approximately 1.2 million abortions in this country each year.

A point of contention for me is that I do not believe that all abortions are evil and wrong. I have to leave room for extreme health circumstances. But I firmly believe that abortion is not a form of birth control. And it shouldn't be treated that way.

So, all of that said. I'm just simply infuriated by "Christians" who protest these clinics. To them I wish I could convey how some of the rest of the world feel when we see these ridiculous protests that benefit no one. They don't save lives. Protests haven't resulted in any marked difference in the number of abortions performed in our country. And protests haven't resulted in a difference in the number Planned Parenthood performs.

There is no measurable result of your holier-than-thou protests. There is no measurable result coming from your marching, your chanting and your arrogant and ignorant dissent.

These people really do practice what is a huge turnoff to me: ala carte Christianity. They pick and choose which portions of The Bible they use to condemn and judge others. In one breath, they chose to become Christians - to follow God, to surrender their lives. But the very next breath condemns choices that others make - using that same free will.

You see, I believe, very firmly God is pro-choice. -- much more, read full post

From RH Reality Check . . .

It is yet to be seen if the call issued today by eastern Illinois religious leaders to spend Sunday as a day of prayer in support of Planned Parenthood will lessen or intensify the debate surrounding the facility.

"To deny women access to, and choice about, abortion, to contraceptives, to sexual education, is essentially to deny them their moral standing," said the Rev. Larry Greenfield, executive minister of the American Baptist Churches of Metro Chicago. "To deny somebody choice is contrary to what I believe to be the teachings of Jesus."

If you would like to help the Aurora Planned Parenthood, here is some information from their website...

If you’re local to the Aurora or Chicago area:
Join other Planned Parenthood supporters for a Pro-choice Rally this Tuesday, September 25th, 5:00pm Aurora City Hall! We will provide t-shirts and signs until we run out to anyone who shows up to stand in support of the Aurora Planned Parenthood health center.

If you can’t make it to the rally you can still take action:

If you’re further away but would still like to be involved, please consider making a donation to support Planned Parenthood.

For more information, check out the links below:

Also see . . .

Anti-Choice In Aurora

When "Pro-Life" Means "Terrorist"

YouTube Videos of Supporters in Aurora

So what do you think? Is God Pro-Choice??? Are You??? What do you think about the controversy in Aurora???

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com

Comments

 

Access to health care

I don't believe in "God" as traditionally defined by mainstream religions, but I do believe that women have the right to health care and to life. And setting aside the issue of abortion for the moment, it is clear that preventing the Planned Parenthood in Aurora from operating is endangering the lives of women. For example, if women don't have access to pap smears, they won't be able to detect and treat cervical cancer. According to the American Cancer Society, approximately 3,700 women will die of cervical cancer in 2007. Further:

The cervical cancer death rate declined by 74% between 1955 and 1992. The main reason for this change is the increased use of the Pap test. This screening procedure can find changes in the cervix before cancer develops. It can also find early cancer in its most curable stage. The death rate from cervical cancer continues to decline by nearly 4% a year.

So it is clear that pap smears save lives. It is thus pro-life to want women to have access to pap smears. Shutting down a clinic that provides this life-saving test to many who would not otherwise access it is pretty hypocritical.

Taking the cervical cancer analogy to its logical conclusion, I assume that anyone who is trying to "save lives" by keeping this clinic closed supports universal health insurance. Because once a woman is diagnosed with cervical cancer, she's going to need treatment to save her life. And if she has no other access to pap smears other than through Planned Parenthood, I'm willing to be she has no insurance since they offer the tests to people who otherwise can't get one elsewhere because they can't afford.

There are many ways to be pro-life. I proudly define myself as a person who saves the lives of women, and I am sure if there is a God, the God would approve of that.

Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants

 

You are absolutely right Suzanne.

Hi Suzanne. When I wrote this post last night, I didn't intend for it to focus so much on the pro-life issue of the controversy. In fact I had a whole post completed and ready to post at about 1am and when I tried to add a picture I lost the entire thing (links and all). After almost an hour of trying to figure out a way to get it back, I gave-up and started writing a new post...and this was the outcome.

Anyway, I agree with you 100%. Planned Parenthood provides so many important services to women, and I think the protesters just choose to blindly overlook that in order to promote their "anti-choice" agenda.

Not only are your statistics absolutely right...but it's also proven that many more abortions take place when low income women don't have access to birth control. So when you think about it that way, the protesters are actually contributing to an increased need for abortions, by denying Planned Parenthood's ability to open and dispense birth control to women who need it.

Thanks for your comments.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com

 

Suzanne, you said "but I do

Suzanne, you said "but I do believe that women have the right to health care and to life."

Don't unborn humans have the right to life, too?

I don't have a problem with women using birth control -- even though as a Catholic I'm supposed to be against the pill. I like to rationalize that God would prefer that an egg not be fertilized than an abortion be performed.

Why do we as women feel we have the right to choose which child will live and which will be terminated?

 

I have a question...

Hi Dana.

I'm Catholic too, but I still have trouble assuming that I or any other mere mortal (Christian or otherwise) can speak to what "God would prefer".

Religion is a wonderful thing, but no one belief should rule over all others...God gave us free will, but he didn't make us the judge and jury of each others choices. Each one of us should do what is right for us, and not judge others over the choices they make.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com

 

The Right to Life

While many people have different beliefs about when life begins based on different religious teachings and different scientific measures (hence you call a fetus a child and I call call it what it technically is - blastocyst, zygote, fetus, etc.), I personally believe that the right to life begins at (or very near) birth, and that right includes:
1. Health care
2. Safe housing
3. Quality education

I am fully prepared to support each child's right to life when he/she is born.

Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants

 

Excellent point...

Hi Suzanne. You make an excellent point...So many children don't even get what I would consider basic human rights (health care, safe home, and quality education). It's so sad that even in our country so many children are neglected and abused, this is an area that could use some of the attention and money that is being spent protesting at women's health clinics. There are actual children out there that really need help, just getting born doesn't assure any kind of quality of life for these children.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com

 

this is such a great post, Catherine

This post makes me want to run out and offer my services to Planned Parenthood. You sum it all up very nicely in this overview.

And I would add to the excellent points that you and Suzanne had made that I would not be surprised if the protesters succeeded in increasing the numbers of later term abortions...

laurie
www.notjustaboutcancer.blogspot.com

 

Thanks Laurie...

I'm glad you like the post, thanks for the comment.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com

 

Bravo

I also appreciate this post.

Personally I think God is "Pro-People". However he does give us the opportunity to both make bad choices (hurting people, especially people who are trying to help others) as well as good ones (like PP and you guys).

I prefer to refer to these people, who call themselves "Pro-life" as proponents of Forced Pregnancy rather than Pro-Life. I want to say Suzanne was the one who coined the phrase but I don't recall offhand. (so by this logic Pro-Life is also Pro-Choice)

Jim Heivilin

 

Thanks Jim...

I agree. You really do get the impression that people who consider themselves "pro-life", are really just "pro-forcing their religious beliefs on others".

Thanks for your comment.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com

 

bumper sticker

A few weeks ago I saw a bumper sticker that said

"Freedom of Religion means all religions."

Jim Heivilin